Hong Kong: Cardinal Zen condemned for a fund to help pro-democracy protesters

Posted on 25 November 2022

Joseph Zen, a 90-year-old cardinal, and five pro-democracy activists from Hong Kong were fined on Friday for improperly setting up a relief fund for arrested protesters.

Cardinal Joseph Zen, one of Asia's most senior Catholic prelates, was arrested in May for "colluding with foreign forces", sparking international outrage.

However, he has not, at this stage, been charged with this offense which would make him incur life imprisonment, according to the national security law imposed by Beijing in 2020.

With his co-defendants, including singer Denise Ho and lawyer Margaret Ng, he was only tried this time for failure to register the fund as a company, an offense punishable by a simple fine.

All had pleaded not guilty and their trial had lasted two months before a Hong Kong judge. Five of the defendants, including Cardinal Zen, were sentenced to a fine of 4.000 dollars (490 euros) and the sixth to 2.500 dollars.

The "612 Humanitarian Relief Fund" was set up to help protesters arrested during the major pro-democracy protests of 2019 finance their defense.

This movement was followed by a severe takeover by Beijing. Most of Hong Kong's pro-democracy figures are now in jail or have fled overseas.

Judge Ada Yim ruled on Friday in her verdict that the aid fund was subject to the registration requirement, because it was not, according to her, a charity but a company whose activity "could affect public order, peace and national security".

The prosecution claimed during the trial that the fund had raised 270 million Hong Kong dollars (33 million euros) from some 103.000 donors, some of which had been spent “on political activities and non-political events. charities” such as donations to overseas pro-democracy groups and activists.

The defense argued that the fund was “merely a name given to a sum of money” and that the defendants did not form a “society”. She also challenged the constitutionality of the 1911 law under which the defendants were being prosecuted.

“The criminalization of failure to register is undoubtedly a restriction of important freedoms for civil society”, had pleaded defense lawyer Gladys Li.

The Editorial Board (with AFP)